#MAKEMKV ANGLE 1 ANGLE 2 FULL#
#MAKEMKV ANGLE 1 ANGLE 2 SOFTWARE#
#MAKEMKV ANGLE 1 ANGLE 2 PC#

PS Edited to add: just noted whatever_gong82's post above, so this is just confirming what he said I guess So I am trusting the developers of both these products. If you compare where clonebd was on launch with today it's an enormous progress. I think they are both great, makemkv is imo more mature right now tbh, but it won't always be so I guess. On the other side, Clonebd can deliver a cinavia-free soundtrack, albeit not in original dts and still with glitches in my brief experience so farĬlonebd obviously has a lot of other functionality and not just mkv, notably to burn clone disks!īoth these products are being actively developed and have their strengths. There is some other functionality where makemkv, today, is better, or in clonebd is even non-existent - handling angles springs to mind for example

#MAKEMKV ANGLE 1 ANGLE 2 SOFTWARE#

PS By the way, Cinavia is enforced on all Blu-ray players made since 2012, and legal Blu-ray playback software made since February 2012 as well.Īt the moment, for making an mkv MakeMKV has still important advantages over clonebd, noteably that clonebd always transcodes whereas makemkv will do passthroughįor this reason, right now Clonebd takes 4x as long to make 1/2 the quality, as mBrane notesīUT VERY IMPORTANTLY we are promised this will not always be so! So, my question to mBrane, is MakeMKV really worth $50 when it can't even handle Cinavia?

#MAKEMKV ANGLE 1 ANGLE 2 PC#

One last thing: with AnyDVD HD, if I wish, I can also play MKVs such as from MakeMKV on my PC if I wish on PowerDVD Ultra versions 12 to 15 and TMT 5/TMT 6, since I legally own all the above software players. I know CloneBD doesn't have the ability to create lossless MKV files yet, but I can wait, because at least I can use this to play MKVs on my Blu-ray player/TV without having the Cinavia shut off message kick in.

That is the deal breaker for me, because at least with the newest AnyDVD HD/CloneBD combo, I can make an MKV from those discs that have Cinavia on them, and play them on my Blu-ray player.

MakeMKV is useless to me because if I convert those discs to a MKV and play them on my Samsumg Blu-ray disc player, the Cinavia shut off signal is activated after about 20 minutes or so. I also own some other discs as well, such as Captain Phillips, The Wedding Ringer, and a few recent and past movies. harder to do.įor example, I own the 21 Jump Street/22 Jump Street Blu-ray disc sets. One thing that I see that CloneBD has in advantage over MakeMKV is that it is always changing, evolving to take on the challenges that the Blu-ray consortium has set up in making legal back up copies of your movies/TV shows, etc. SamuriHL is one of the Moderators on this site, and he uses MakeMKV, by the way. MakeMKV is a nice little program, but to me, it is a complement to, but no way better than, the AnyDVD HD/CloneBD combination in which I own. Detractors still remain: no support for DVDs, the performance issue documented above, and the price. About the only thing that I've identified is the AnyDVD HD Cinavia integration w/ CloneBD. Here are the video track differences when using each tool in 'lossless' mode:Īgain, looking for a good reason to support CloneBD.

#MAKEMKV ANGLE 1 ANGLE 2 FULL#

These videos were playing simultaneously from the same position in the video track (my system can easily play multiple instances at full framerates, so don't point at me). That's absolutely hideous! The CloneBD instance can't even hit half the target framerate of 23.976. * the top MPC instance is playing the MKV generated by CloneBD, and the bottom is MakeMKV. Yikes! :doh: What a difference!Ĭheck out the performance difference, when playing back in MPC-HC 64-bit (v1.7.9) on a Core i7 with 6 cores 3.2 GHz, 32 GB, and dual nVIDIA GTX 680's: I conducted a test between the products: a lossless conversion of a Bluray title to MKV. Decrypted backup will contain all files from original disc but M2TS files will be decrypted (both AACS and BD+ will be removed).'

'MakeMKV can create a decrypted backup of a Blu-ray disc on a hard drive. 'MakeMKV supports all commercial Blu-ray discs protected by latest versions of AACS and BD+.'

For starters, I *have* read MakeMKV's site, which *clearly* indicates that: You are jumping to a lot of conclusions yourself. ' very misinformed.' How funny of you to use an amplifier with a binary term. No need to be condescending, Recycle (ie. Click to expand.Unfortunately, my reply to SlyFox 1 was blocked by this site earlier.

Makemkv angle 1 angle 2